Indie Rom-Coms to Watch After Bread and Butter

If Bread and Butter left you in the mood for more love stories that are a little crooked, a little awkward and very human, this list is for you. Some of these films are gentle and some are sharp, and none of them is a by-the-numbers romance. We have stuck to independent and independent-spirited films, and to facts we can vouch for: the year, the director and why each one belongs on a shelf next to ours.

The watchlist at a glance

FilmYearDirectorWatch it if you liked…
Me and You and Everyone We Know2005Miranda JulyLonely oddballs treated with tenderness
Obvious Child2014Gillian RobespierreA heroine sorting out her own life first
Before Sunrise1995Richard LinklaterRomance built out of conversation
Punch-Drunk Love2002Paul Thomas AndersonAn anxious lead with a loud inner life
Ruby Sparks2012Jonathan Dayton, Valerie FarisFalling for someone you have imagined
Drinking Buddies2013Joe SwanbergLoose, low-budget, lived-in awkwardness
Celeste and Jesse Forever2012Lee Toland KriegerHonesty about relationships that no longer fit
Medicine for Melancholy2008Barry JenkinsA quiet two-hander
Sleeping with Other People2015Leslye HeadlandA film that bends rom-com rules for fun
The Big Sick2017Michael ShowalterAwkward family dinners

The films, one by one

Me and You and Everyone We Know (2005)

Miranda July wrote, directed and starred in this debut about a lonely artist and a newly separated shoe salesman, surrounded by kids and neighbors who are all trying to connect in peculiar ways. A critic at Hammer to Nail compared Liz Manashil's script to it, and the comparison makes sense: both films find comedy in people who are slightly out of step with everyone else, and both treat that loneliness with care instead of mockery.

Obvious Child (2014)

Gillian Robespierre's feature stars Jenny Slate as a Brooklyn stand-up comic who, after a breakup and a one-night stand, faces an unplanned pregnancy. It reached audiences in 2014, the same year our film premiered at Woodstock, and it shares our interest in a woman figuring out her own life with a man nearby rather than at the center of the frame.

Before Sunrise (1995)

Two strangers, played by Ethan Hawke and Julie Delpy, get off a train in Vienna and walk and talk until morning. Almost nothing happens and everything does. If you liked the moments where Amelia talks herself into a feeling and then straight back out of it, Richard Linklater's film is the masterclass.

Punch-Drunk Love (2002)

Paul Thomas Anderson cast Adam Sandler as a lonely, anxious small-business owner with seven sisters and a temper he cannot explain, and Emily Watson as the woman who sees past all of it. It is genuinely romantic, but it is also about a person whose inner life is much louder than anyone around him realizes. Amelia would recognize him at once.

Ruby Sparks (2012)

Directed by Jonathan Dayton and Valerie Faris from a script by Zoe Kazan, who also stars, the film imagines a novelist whose fictional dream girl comes to life. It turns into a sharp look at what happens when you love a version of someone you invented. Amelia falls for Leonard through the notes he left in a book, before she has met him, so this one sits very close to our story. We dig into that idea in Notes in the Margins: Books as Romance Devices.

Drinking Buddies (2013)

Joe Swanberg's Chicago comedy stars Olivia Wilde and Jake Johnson as co-workers at a craft brewery who are clearly drawn to each other while both are seeing other people. Much of the dialogue was improvised, and the film has the loose, unvarnished feel that small productions do best. If you are curious about that side of filmmaking, read our lessons from shooting a low-budget comedy.

Celeste and Jesse Forever (2012)

Rashida Jones co-wrote this film with Will McCormack and stars opposite Andy Samberg as a divorcing couple trying to stay best friends. It is funny, then painful, then honest about how hard it is to let go of a relationship that has stopped fitting.

Medicine for Melancholy (2008)

Years before Moonlight, Barry Jenkins made this quiet, mostly two-person film about strangers in San Francisco who spend the day after a one-night stand together. It is as much about the city, and who gets to feel at home in it, as it is about romance.

Sleeping with Other People (2015)

Leslye Headland's comedy pairs Alison Brie and Jason Sudeikis as two serial cheaters who become close friends and agree not to sleep together. It plays with the rules of the genre while openly enjoying them.

The Big Sick (2017)

Written by Kumail Nanjiani and Emily V. Gordon and based on the early days of their own relationship, it follows a comic whose girlfriend is placed in a medically induced coma. It is the most conventional love story here, and it is still full of uncomfortable family dinners that would feel at home in the Karinsky household.

Portrait of actress Christine Weatherup in a floral dress against a dark curtain
Christine Weatherup, who plays Amelia Karinsky in Bread and Butter.

Build your own double feature

Bread and Butter runs about an hour and a half, which makes it an easy first half of a double bill. A few pairings we like:

  • Bread and Butter + Ruby Sparks: two films about falling for a person you have partly made up.
  • Bread and Butter + Punch-Drunk Love: anxious leads, big hearts, unexpected tenderness.
  • Bread and Butter + Me and You and Everyone We Know: lonely oddballs, gently observed.
  • Bread and Butter + Obvious Child: women at the center of their own stories.

If you want to know what we mean by the label on our poster, start with What Is an Anti-Romantic Comedy? And if you have not seen our film yet, The Orchard released it on digital, cable and satellite platforms; the How to See Bread and Butter page lists them.