Why We Root for Both Sides of a Love Triangle

Every love triangle asks the audience to pick a side, and most of us cheat: we pick both. In Bread and Butter, Amelia is pulled between Leonard, the brooding stranger whose pencil notes she finds in a used book, and Daniel, the affable client of her boss who courts her sincerely. The Cleveland International Film Festival's program note described a love triangle "pitting both sides of Amelia's romantic notions against each other," and that phrase gets close to why triangles work so well on screen.

A triangle is really an argument

The best triangles are not about two suitors at all. They are about two ideas of love. One suitor usually stands for mystery, excitement and risk; the other for kindness, comfort and safety. The person in the middle is not just choosing a partner. She is choosing between versions of herself, the person she might become with one or the other.

Here is how that argument plays out in our film, using only what the synopses tell you before you press play:

LeonardDaniel
How Amelia meets himThrough the notes he scribbled in the margins of a bookAt work: he is a client of her boss
What he stands forOriginality, unpredictability, the romance she has read aboutKindness, familiarity, someone with her own fears and quirks
What he offersAn idea she has already fallen forGood intentions and genuine attention
The catchThe real man is living with clinical depressionA real relationship is more frightening than an imagined one

Why we end up rooting for both

Because each suitor is right about something

A fair triangle gives each side a real virtue. The exciting one is right that life should have some magic in it. The steady one is right that love is built out of showing up. When both claims are true, the audience cannot settle the question in five minutes, and neither can the heroine.

Because we recognize ourselves in the middle

Most people have felt the pull between the person who dazzles them and the person who is good for them. Watching someone else face that choice lets us replay our own, safely, from a seat in the dark.

Because suspense needs a fair fight

If one option is obviously wrong, there is no story, only a delay. Writers know this, which is why the "wrong" suitor in a well-made triangle is rarely a villain. He is just wrong for her, or wrong for now.

Because the triangle lets us try on two lives

Each suitor comes with a different future attached: a different apartment, different friends, a different version of Sunday morning. For ninety minutes we get to live in both futures at once. Choosing one means losing the other, and part of us does not want to give either up.

Portrait of actor Micah Hauptman in a gray T-shirt against a dark curtain
Micah Hauptman, who plays Leonard Marsh, the stranger behind the notes in the margins.

Triangles that refused the easy answer

  • The Philadelphia Story (1940). On the eve of her second wedding, Katharine Hepburn's Tracy Lord finds herself between her stiff fiancé, her ex-husband, played by Cary Grant, and a reporter, played by James Stewart. The film is really about Tracy learning to forgive her own imperfections.
  • Casablanca (1942). Rick and Ilsa love each other, and Victor Laszlo is a good man. Rick sends Ilsa away with her husband. The romance loses to something bigger, and audiences have loved it for over eighty years.
  • Broadcast News (1987). Holly Hunter's TV producer, Jane, is torn between the handsome, shallow anchor played by William Hurt and her brilliant, prickly friend played by Albert Brooks. She ends up with neither of them. James L. Brooks made one of the great triangle films by refusing to close it.
  • Bridget Jones's Diary (2001). Charming cad or awkward decent man? The triangle tests what Bridget actually wants, and the film has fun making both men ridiculous in different ways.

The third side of the triangle

Here is the secret of the anti-romantic triangle: the person in the middle has a third option, which is to put herself first. Our synopsis says it outright. Bread and Butter is the story of a lonely person who finally decides to strike out on her own after learning that romance is not the only way to fulfill her desires. That does not make Leonard or Daniel villains. It means the triangle was never really about them.

That is also why a viewer who argues loudly for one of the men can still leave the film satisfied. They were right to like him. He just was not the point. If that idea is new to you, our explainer What Is an Anti-Romantic Comedy? walks through the genre.

Does the audience ever agree?

Rarely, and that is a sign the triangle is working. Ask any group of friends after a good triangle film which suitor deserved the heroine, and you will usually get both answers, delivered with equal conviction. In our story, a viewer drawn to restless, original minds will make the case for Leonard, while a viewer who values patience and honesty will argue just as hard for Daniel. When an audience splits like that, it means both characters have been written and played as people rather than as plot devices, and the argument on the way home becomes part of the experience.

How writers keep a triangle fair

  1. Give each suitor at least one scene where he is clearly right.
  2. Give each a flaw that is human rather than cruel.
  3. Let the person in the middle want things that genuinely conflict.
  4. Show the cost of each choice, not just the reward.
  5. Let the audience change its mind at least once.
  6. Decide early whether the story is about the choice or about the chooser.

Daniel is played by Bobby Moynihan, and we wrote a separate guide to his film roles beyond SNL. Leonard is played by Micah Hauptman, and the full cast is on our Cast & Crew page.